• About Jess and the Dogs
  • The Books I Write
  • Contact Me
Books and dogs

Books and Dogs

A blog about books and dogs

  • Book Blog
  • In The Stacks
  • About Jess and the Dogs
You are here: Home / Theatrical Adaptations / Agatha Christie’s And Then There Were None and Its Theatrical Adaptations

Agatha Christie’s And Then There Were None and Its Theatrical Adaptations

Theatrical Adaptations

If Agatha Christie is the queen of mystery, she is also the repeated victim of theatrical adaptations.

I’m sure like many of you here, I’m a big Agatha Christie fan. Her work reminds me a lot of Edgar Allen Poe, of whom I am also a big fan. I enjoy the deceptively simple set up of Christie’s mysteries that inevitably leave you scratching your head.

Take Murder on the Orient Express. A man is murdered in his train compartment, but at the supposed time of death, he was alone. Seems impossibly simple, right?

Put this against The Purloined Letter by Poe. The object of the story is a letter being used for blackmail and the question in regards to its whereabouts. I don’t do spoilers here, so you’ll need to check out that short story for yourself, but I’ll give you a hint. The solution is simple as well.

But back to Christie –

One of my favorite Christie novels is And Then There Were None. I always hear the argument that every story has been done before, and Christie set the bar for the group murder. (Clue anyone?)

And Then There Were None

This mystery novel was first published in 1939 in the UK under a title which is rather controversial in today’s world. So I’ll just link to it so you can see it for yourself. It’s interesting because the novel was reprinted from 1964-1986 under a different controversial name. But for the most part in this US, this mystery book has been known as And Then There Were None, based on the last words of the popular poem on which the plot is draped.

The poem is a nursery rhyme that has been adapted over time to use different words such as Indians. But the adaptations largely use the poem that substitutes Indians with soldiers. You can see a version of it here.

Ten strangers are lured to an island home off the coast of Devon by a mystery man that each of them know only as U.N. Owen. Each are brought under different false pretenses, and once assembled are excused of murder through a recording on a record. One by one the individuals are murdered as atonement for their misdeeds.

It’s a great book. Definitely read it. But what I want to touch on today are the theatrical adaptations.

The Theatrical Adaptations

I’m always curious to see how a book might be adapted into a movie or television show because a visual medium is so different from a written one. For instance, I’m curious to see how Eleanor Oliphant will be adapted because so much occurs in the character’s mind.

And Then There Were None has had several theatrical adaptations, and the reason I say Christie is the victim of adaptations is that none of these productions keep the original ending from the book.

That is until now.

In 2015, the marvelous people at the BBC distributed an adaptation by Mammoth Screen/Agatha Christie Productions/Acorn Productions/A&E Networks that keeps the original novel’s ending!

As a fangirl, this was better than a book sale when I discovered this mystery miniseries. (It recently aired on PBS in the US in case you missed it!)

Now I don’t do spoilers, so I’m not going to say what happens at the end that makes me tickled pink about this miniseries, but I will say this.

The novel has a richly DARK ending. Far too dark for a visual medium at the time the book was published so you won’t see it in the earlier adaptations for television or film. (If you’re looking for an example, I recommend the 1965 version directed by George Pollock.) A writer on the 2015 production was said to have spoken about this dark ending because it’s so unlike Christie’s other works. Poirot or Marple (Christie’s most famous characters arguably) are always there in the end to interpret and save the day. Not so here. This story is disturbingly without redemption.

Now I just praised this adaptation for sticking to the script, right?

Well, I’m also going to praise it for WILDY DEVIATING from the script.

The Characters

This miniseries is thick with character building. In the book, you learn what each person is accused of, but there’s either an explanation that pardons them from their crime or they, in fact, just didn’t do it. We never learn much else about them. In this miniseries, not so much. These characters are EVIL, and I LOVED it. The adaptation never faltered from the guilty sentences placed on these doomed individuals, and it made it that more exciting. Their backstories were told through gripping, startling scenes until you could taste their guilt.

The cast is riddled with amazing talent, but if I’m talking to the right crowd, I need only say Aidan Turner plays Lombard. (Yes, Poldark, people.)

Yes, I loved this theatrical adaptation, and yes, I think the book can in many ways always be better, but To Kill a Mockingbird has taught me to say the book isn’t ALWAYS better. Sometimes it’s just different.

Have you seen an adaptation of And Then There Were None?

Tell us what you thought about it in the comments – but please, no spoilers!

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
Share
Pin1
Tweet
1 Shares

September 10, 2019 ·

Disclosure of Material Connection

Some of the links in the page above are “affiliate links.” This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, I will receive an affiliate commission. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”

Previous Post: « A Look at Where’d You Go Bernadette by Maria Semple, a Women’s Fiction Novel
Next Post: A Look At A Man Called Ove by Fredrik Backman, a Contemporary Fiction Book »

Primary Sidebar

Welcome to the blog about books and dogs.

I'm Jess and these are the dogs. Come on in, and let's find your next favorite read. Read More…

Browse by Category

Subscribe to Books & Dogs via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Search

Let’s connect.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • YouTube

Find Your New Favorite Author

a.g. riddle abby jimenez alex michaelides alex north beatriz williams camilla sten charlotte bronte christina lauren daisy prescott deanna raybourn diana gabaldon elle cosimano elly griffiths erica ridley j. ryan stradal jane austen jerry seinfeld joanna schaffhausen julia quinn karen odden karen white kate bateman katherine center kendra adachi laura dave laura zigman lauren willig liane moriarty lisa kleypas loretta chase lucy foley lynn kurland matt haig mike rowe nedra glover tawwab orson scott card rick riordan ruth ware sally thorne sarah maclean sarah pinborough shari lapena simone st. james teri wilson tessa dare
  • Privacy Policy
  • Copyright Policy
  • Disclosures and Disclaimers
Have I mentioned this really hot sale of steamy hi Have I mentioned this really hot sale of steamy historical romance novels? Maybe once or twice? ⁣
⁣
Time is running out to save big and fill your ereaders with historical romances that are sure to keep you warm this winter. Check out the sale now by following the link in my bio!⁣
⁣
#historicalromance #romancebooks #books #reading #hothistoricalromance #ebook
I'm so glad I gave Not a Happy Family by Shari Lap I'm so glad I gave Not a Happy Family by Shari Lapena a second chance. I had started it as an ebook and just couldn't get into it, but when I switched to audiobook, I was hooked. This is just another example of how changing a book's format may help the reader engage with the story. I definitely recommend this strategy if you're just not getting into a book you thought you might love.⁣
⁣
Not a Happy Family is a fantastic whodunit mystery with a delicious, unsavory cast that you can never trust. If you're looking for great, twisted mystery to curl up with, this might be for you. Check out the full discussion on the book blog. Link in my bio! ⁣
⁣
#whodunit #mystery #agathachristie #murdermystery #thrillers #psychologicalthriller #murdercase #cozymystery
Have you stopped by the Cold Nights, Hot Historica Have you stopped by the Cold Nights, Hot Historicals ebook sale yet? ⁣
⁣
You'll find When the Earl Falls in Love for only $0.99 for a very limited time in select markets. Get started on The Secret Matchmaker series before the next book in the series comes out next month!⁣
⁣
Link for the sale is in my bio!⁣
⁣
#secretmatchmaker #historicalromancenovels #romancenovels #amreadingromance #romancereaders #readers #readersofig #amreading #ebooksale #booksale #discountedbooks
FREE BOOK!⁣ ⁣ The Marquess She Loved is FREE f FREE BOOK!⁣
⁣
The Marquess She Loved is FREE for a very limited time! ⁣
⁣
She's loved him forever. But he only has eyes for someone else. But when fate throws them together, can they find their way to love?⁣
⁣
This is the second book in the Atwood Sisters series, and a friends to lovers historical romance. ⁣
⁣
Link is in my bio!⁣
⁣
#freebook #romancenovel #victorianromance #atwoodsisters #series #books #bookworm
Looking for some snowy reads to snuggle up with th Looking for some snowy reads to snuggle up with this winter?⁣
⁣
Definitely check out Ruth Ware's In a Dark Dark Wood. This is a locked room, Agatha Christie-type mystery of whodunit, and I love how Ware has constructed the story to unfold with the unreliable narrator in the present trying to remember the past. Brilliantly done to raise the stakes and ramp up the tension.⁣
⁣
Check out my full discussion at the link in my bio.⁣
⁣
#bookblog #mystery #thriller #bookstagrammer #booksta #booksanddogs #books #amreading #readers #mysterybooks #mysterynovels #thrillerbooks #suspense #agathachristie
Did you know my audiobooks are now on Spotify?⁣ Did you know my audiobooks are now on Spotify?⁣
⁣
Head on over and take a listen at the link in my bio!⁣
⁣
#audiobooks #dukes #romance #spotify #amlistening #audiobookstagram #wallflowers
It’s time to meet the Shadowing London series. It’s time to meet the Shadowing London series. 

This series remains a fan favorite, and it’s not hard to see why. Each story is full of the tropes you love, yes, but they’re also packed with mystery, adventure, and daring. If you’re looking for historical mystery with romantic elements, don’t miss the Shadowing London series.

#shadowinglondon #spies #spybooks #romancebooks #historicalromance #historicalmystery #mystery #thrillerbooks
Looking to warm up this winter? ⁣ ⁣ I've teame Looking to warm up this winter? ⁣
⁣
I've teamed up with some of your favorite historical romance authors to bring you Cold Nights, Hot Historicals. Check out this collection of discounted steamy historical romances and fill up your ereaders for those cold, winter nights!⁣
⁣
Link in bio!⁣
⁣
#historicalromance #booksale #ebooksale #ebooks #ereaders #kindle #nook #amreading #readers #readersofig #romancereaders
Here I am once again asking you to join my newslet Here I am once again asking you to join my newsletter. Here's why.⁣
⁣
1. You will be the first to know when something really cool happens like a pre-order, a sale, or behind the scenes things like pictures of my dogs napping. ⁣
2. Amazon only shows you my books that it thinks you'll like based on your purchasing history. It won't show you all of them. So to get the whole picture, you want to be a part of this club.⁣
3. I host incredible guest authors, and we have a lot of fun. Are you always looking for new authors to binge? You'll find them in my newsletter.⁣
4. Isn't 1-3 enough? I'm going to need far more coffee to come up with a fourth reason.⁣
⁣
Join today at the link in my bio.⁣
⁣
#authorlife #authors #authorsofig #writer #writerlife #amwriting #readers #readersrock #readersarecool #ilovereaders

Disclosure of Material Connection

Some of the links in the page above are “affiliate links.” This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, I will receive an affiliate commission. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”

Amazon Affiliate Disclosure

Books & Dogs is a participant in the Amazon Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and its affiliated sites. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Copyright © 2022 · Anchored Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in